Sticky songs: Are earworms a sign of songwriting success?

When someone tells me that one of my songs got stuck in his/her head, I take it as a high compliment. After all, how great is it to know that a song I wrote is echoing in a person’s brain, over and over?

However, I also know how awful it can be when someone’s sticky song gets stuck in my head. Sure, it might be a song I like, but must I listen to it over and over and over until I want to scream?

I even have songs I can hardly listen to because I know they will immediately cause an earworm. Really, any Abba song, listened to late in the evening, can cause a sleepless night. I’m not even immune to indie tunes: I consider my friend Mark Allen Berube positively brilliant when it comes to creating sticky songs, to the point that I refuse to even include his album “Suspicious Fish” on my iPod in case it comes on shuffle and I go through my day endlessly singing “The Naked Guy at the Gym” or “Grandma Gave me the Finger.”

I asked the Songwriting Scene communities on Facebook and Twitter for their sticky song feedback. Here’s what some songwriters had to say:

Kay Ashley: “Years ago I saw Leo Kottke in concert and he talked about earworms. His worst earworm was ‘Yummy, Yummy, Yummy I’ve Got Love in My Tummy” and the only way he could get it out of his head was to transcribe the tune onto paper and then sing it backwards. His theory was that he canceled it out mathematically.”

Tara Covington: “How about ‘Fly Me to the Moon”….I want to send it to the moon. I can’t understand why, hippie child that I was…of all the things that could worm way down deep into my head. I get caught humming it at work a few times a week. Anybody know an antidote for major earworm humming disease?:

Lydia Wagner: “My vote: Dancin’ in the Moonlight by King Harvest. the second you hear those notes in the intro…sooo catchy.”

Michael Leahy: “The two stickiest composers I know are Abba and Johann Strauss. Others might try hard, but never get there.”


What’s your vote for the stickiest song? What causes your earworms? Do tell!

  • joe iadanza

    My daughter has been playing Anton Diabelli's Op 163 Jugenfreuden for two months. I've been trying to think of a sticky song for you, but all I've been hearing is that! :)

  • Meg

    As you know, "Surrey with the Fringe on Top" kept me awake most of the night last night…

  • Shannon Wagner

    Alice's Restaurant! And, anything by Mark Berube.

  • MAB

    Aw, I am so flattered. Really. Thanks for not playing me!

    There are two kinds of sticky for me. Sticky #1 is a hooky hooky pop hook. Guitars! Fountains of Wayne and Weezer are good at this. "Stacy's Mom" and "Buddy Holly" can hang around all day.

    Sticky #2 is a plain old great melody. These don't just stay in my head all day. They come out my mouth. I can't help singing them. I love the way a fine melody makes my mouth feel. I find myself moving my hands or my head or my whole body up and down with the notes like I'm riding a wave.

    Three masters of this are Leonard Cohen ("Sisters of Mercy" is splendid; and how about that "Famous Blue Raincoat"?), Carole King (who I never cared for much until I found myself singing "So Far Away" over and over; "Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow?" is also great) and the immortal Cole Porter ("Night and Day" is hands-down the greatest melody ever written; I'm not kidding).

  • cinderkeys

    The first song I think of when this topic comes up is …

    Hmm. I don't remember the name of it. But claymation Christmas-special fans should recognize the lyrics:

    I'm Mr. Heatmeiser
    I'm Mr. Sun
    I'm Mr. Green Christmas
    I'm Mr. Hundred and One

    Eeeeeeeeee!!!

    Because of songs like this, I only take stickiness as a compliment if someone *likes* having the song in their head. :)

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Jimmeria-Powers/707388065 Jimmeria Powers

    I know this is very stupid for me to say this, but it had to be Alicia Keys’ “Fallin’”. I don’t know why, but…Okay, let’s put it that way. It begins with those four words in the very beginning of the song that will make you find many ways to sing it out of your head or improvise it (“I keep on fallin’ in…”) I found that kinda sticky because it is the kind of song you…say you wanted to make love to.